or the Mischief of Cheshire Cat
Here is the untold story about the secret link between the Galaxy, the Master Plan and the Mother’s Symbol. A very interesting story, indeed, which may be at the root of a lot of confusion in the present debate about clearing the 12 radials and the outer ring road, a story which may remind us of a famous tale cherished by many kids, young and old, all over the world …
But first, before we go down the rabbit hole, let’s look at the facts…
On 23 June 1965, when Mother described to Satprem her plan of the future town, she said: “At the time [early 1938] I told Antonin Raymond, who built “Golconde,” about the project, and he was enthusiastic, he told me, “As soon as you start building, call me and I will come.”
“I showed him my plan (it was on the model of the [my] symbol, enlarged), and he was quite enthusiastic, he found it magnificent. It fell through.”
In all likelihood, Mother had sent to Roger a transcript of this entire conversation in order to brief him on the plan she has just “received”. This probably explains why the road network of the Nebula model is based on Mother’s symbol.
“Nebula” concept, early 1966
Its roads network is based on Mother’s symbol.
But The Mother was not convinced by this first design and Roger worked for about two years on various options till he finally designed the Galaxy Model in 1968.
One of these, the Macrostructure, designed in 1967, was based on a deformed symbol of The Mother:
“Macrostructure” concept, 1967
Its road network is based on a deformed symbol of the Mother.
Then, in 1968, the first master plan of the Galaxy model, shows clearly 12 equidistant curved radials but two of them are in doted lines indicating that they are optional (if not built we would have then 10 or 11 radials which, at once, would disconnect the road network from the Mother’s symbol).
“Galaxy” plan. Drawing dated January 1968.
In 1969, Roger designed a new master plan. It was part of a “Study of the Town Plan – First Approach” prepared by Roger and his Paris team and it was sent to Ford Foundation on March 13th 1969 with an accompanying letter signed by Mother.
“Galaxy”, plan of the road network, 1969
As we can see, the plan display only 9 radials and The Mother’s symbol disappeared
Interestingly, the 1969 Master Plan had to be modified following the rotation of the galaxy by 50° CCW in July 1971. It seems that the reason for rotating the Galaxy was because the Bharat Nivas had been built at the wrong place (which should have been within the International Zone). When the problem was presented to The Mother she just took the plan and rotated it in such a way that the BN was now properly sitting in the International Zone (correct me if I am wrong).
“Galaxy” Master Plan, from July 1971 onwards
9 radials and no more Mother’s symbol
So, except for the rotation of the entire concept, the 1971 Master Plan is exactly the same as that of 1969. As Roger will modify the galaxy’s road network in 1988 only, this concept of road network remained unchanged during 19 years (1969-88). It is the last official one during Mother’s lifetime. 9 radials and no more symbol.
Interestingly, when we superimpose the 1971 road map to the original Galaxy, it almost perfectly match with the galaxy model approved by the Mother :
This plan is the plan which remained unchanged during 19 years (1969-88)
and the last official one during Mother’s lifetime.
In 1975, as the bulk of the community and the S.A.S. were fighting an open battle, there was no money whatsoever for development. As Roger was attacked by Huta and her supporters regarding his plans of the Urn and of the town, he sends a letter in which he announced his “withdrawal from all Auroville activities” and acts on it. Nobody knew whether Auroville would survive this ordeal and whether Roger will ever return – and, if so, when?
But after a long absence of about 10 years, Roger did start to visit Auroville again in 1985 and in 1988 he became de facto in charge of Auroville’s planning. It is during this period (between 1988 and 1999) that a new road map with 12 equidistant radials was re-introduced (4 of which in dotted lines as optional), the radials being “the dynamic representation of the Mother’s symbol” (Auroville Mobility Plan 2005). This plan was the one ratified by the Residents Assembly in 1999:
Master Plan 1999 – Approved by Residents Assembly
12 radials (4 in dotted lines) and the Mother’s symbol reappears
Now, in the 2001 printed master plan approved by the H.R.D. Ministry four radials disappear and we are left with only 8. Once again the Mother’s symbol disappear…
Master Plan 2001 – approved by the H.R.D Ministry
8 radials and the Mother’s symbol disappears
Finally, in 2004 a new master plan is produced with again 12 radials and it seems that’s what we are supposed to implement today.
Master Plan 2004
12 radials and the Mother’s symbol reappears
Now, let’s summarize:
1966 – “Nebula” concept – 12 radials – based on Mother’s symbol.
1967 – “Macrostructure” concept – 12 radials – deformed Symbol.
1968 – “Galaxy” concept – 10 equidistant radials + 2… – deformed Symbol.
1969/1988 – “Galaxy” master plan – 9 radials – no more Mother’s symbol
1999 – Master plan approved by the RA – 8 radials + 4 …
2001 – Master plan approved by HRD – 8 radials – no more Symbol
2004 – Master plan 2004 – 12 radials and the Mother’s symbol
The story of the 12 radials and the Mother’s symbol appearing and suddenly disappearing throughout all these years sounds a bit like a mischief of the Cheshire Cat in wonderland, isn’t it? And this time again, Alice seems to be a little lost…
And we too.
Now, shall we, with Alice, ask our way to the Cheshire Cat?
Alice : “Cheshire Puss, would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?’
Cheshire Cat: “That depends a good deal on where you want to get to”
Alice : “I don’t much care where…”
Cheshire Cat : “Then it doesn’t matter which way you go”
Alice : “… so long as I get SOMEWHERE”…
Cheshire Cat : “Oh, you’re sure to do that if you only walk long enough.”
Alice : “What sort of people live about here?”
Cheshire Cat : “In THAT direction lives a Hatter. And in THAT direction lives a March Hare. Visit either you like: they’re both mad.”
Alice : “But I don’t want to go among mad people”.
Cheshire Cat : “Oh, you can’t help that, we’re all mad here. I’m mad. You’re mad.”
Alice : “How do you know I’m mad?”
Cheshire Cat : “You must be or you wouldn’t have come here.”
Alice didn’t think that proved it at all; however, she went on…
Alice : “And how do you know that you’re mad?”
Cheshire Cat : “To begin with a dog’s not mad. You grant that?”
Alice : “I suppose so”.
Cheshire Cat : “Well, then, you see, a dog growls when it’s angry, and wags its tail when it’s pleased. Now I growl when I’m pleased, and wag my tail when I’m angry. Therefore I’m mad.”
Alice : “I call it purring, not growling”
Cheshire Cat : “Call it what you like.” And then the Cat vanished.
Alice was not much surprised at this, she was getting so used to queer things happening. While she was looking at the place where it had been, it suddenly appeared again.
Cheshire Cat : “By-the-bye, what became of the baby? I’d nearly forgotten to ask.’
Alice : “It turned into a pig”
Cheshire Cat : “I thought it would”
And then the Cat vanished again to reappear little later, sitting on a branch of a tree.
Cheshire Cat : “Did you say pig, or fig?”
Alice : “I said pig and I wish you wouldn’t keep appearing and vanishing so suddenly: you make one quite giddy.”
Cheshire Cat : “All right”
And this time it vanished quite slowly, beginning with the end of the tail, and ending with the grin, which remained some time after the rest of it had gone.
Alice : “Well! I’ve often seen a cat without a grin, but a grin without a cat! It’s the most curious thing I ever say in my life!”
To tell you the truth, I confess that, me too, I’ve never see a grin without a cat. Did you? But thanks to Alice and her friend, we are now having a clearer picture of were we are, isn’t it?
The Mad Hatter
* * *
PS: Could we get out for a moment of this surrealist dream and ask ourselves a few simple questions:
1. By trying to adapt the Mother’s symbol to the Galaxy and vice versa, aren’t we going to get something which will look neither like the symbol nor the original Galaxy model?
2. Isn’t it that the hectic development of the radials concept obviously shows a lack of conviction and consistency from the architects and planners? And can we therefore say that the embedding of the symbol in the Galaxy might not necessarily be part of the Mother’s “vision” for the city, especially if we consider that on the last plan approved by her there was only 9 radials?
3. If this is the case, then, can we say that the number or radials should be defined according to the mobility NEEDS instead of a particular symbolic meaning?
4. Consequently, wouldn’t it make sense to clear and build the roads only according to the PRESENT needs and see how things evolve and how many of these radials we will finally need for the whole city without anticipating?
These are important questions that need to be answered before any clearing are happening for the radials and outer ring road, otherwise we may end up with an other surrealistic situation but, this time, I’m afraid it will not be a dream from Wonderland…